Should Qantas' Project Sunrise business class seats have doors?

Should Qantas' Project Sunrise business class seats have doors?

TALKING POINT | All of a sudden, doors are the thing for business class. Four airlines already have them – most recently, British Airways with its new Club Suites – and little doubt that other airlines will tap this trend in the years to come.

Which brings us to Qantas’ next-generation business class seats, which will take wing on the Project Sunrise jets from 2022 as they soar non-stop from Sydney and Melbourne to London and New York, with other routes also on the map.

Before this year is out, Qantas will announce if the prestigious Project Sunrise contract will land in the lap of Airbus (for the A350-1000) or Boeing (for the 777X), and the clock will start ticking towards delivery of that first globe-striding jet.

Part of that process is the design of the new seats which Qantas has promised from tip to tail – a process which Qantas has already begun, in order to meet the necessary lead times, with Alan Joyce earlier this year promising that "we’re looking at redefining business class, first class, premium economy and economy."

Which raises the question: should those business class seats actually be suites with doors?

Business travellers I speak with seem broadly split on the idea of doors, even in first class cabins. 

Connected to this seems to be the size of the space: passengers can feel confined in smaller suites once the door is pulled shut.

And while doors can help create a quieter and more private environment when it’s time to sleep (which will be a major component of those marathon Project Sunrise flights), they’re a bit of a barrier to attentive crew service during the rest of the flight.

However, there’s no denying their popularity among those airlines who have them and the premium passengers who fly them.

So this week, we’re asking Australian Business Traveller readers to share their thoughts with Qantas (we know they’re reading!) on Project Sunrise business class: doors or no doors?

David Flynn
David Flynn is the editor of Australian Business Traveller and a bit of a travel tragic with a weakness for good coffee, shopping and lychee martinis.
 

47 comments

  • pungpui

    pungpui

    12 Apr, 2019 06:26 am

    In short, yes! If you want privacy, you can close the door. If you want a bit more of an airy feel, just leave them open. It’s all about choice! Choice is the luxury.
    No member give thanks

  • harry77

    harry77

    12 Apr, 2019 07:08 am

    The Doors would be welcome on my flight. A little ‘Riders on the Storm’ or ‘Waiting for the (project) Sun (rise)’ would while the hours away...
    No member give thanks

  • eddies

    eddies

    12 Apr, 2019 06:30 pm

    It’d be like a little lady in the city of lights.
    No member give thanks

  • RTWFF

    RTWFF

    12 Apr, 2019 07:45 am

    Rod Liddle in the latest Spectator has coined a new phrase “peak wank”. It certainly applies here
    No member give thanks

  • Balta  Caceres

    Aircraft Lover

    12 Apr, 2019 07:47 am

    I think that Business Class seat-suite is a great option

    Most of the Business Class passengers travel alone

    The door gives the possibility of extra privacy if needed
    No member give thanks

  • Pilotpetesyd

    Pilotpetesyd

    12 Apr, 2019 07:55 am

    Qantas has the mantra that their ‘service’ is the key to their product delivery. This isn’t enough any more. We have 4 business class generations in service to date and they’re already working on #5 with project sunrise.

    One thing that Qantas doesn’t do, is engage their top tier flyers (who will fly other airlines) for advice nor look at what the competition is doing. For premium flyers on 17+ hour flights, the seat needs to be private and the cabin needs areas to get away from your seat (a bar & lounge).

    If the Qsuite is winning awards and even the new BA J seat is getting doors, no doubt Qantas will implement something from a few generations ago and bang on that their service will make 17 hours in the sky relaxing and comfortable!
    No member give thanks

  • BatteryBen

    BatteryBen

    14 Apr, 2019 05:33 pm

    I was involved in Qantas focus groups for Project Sunrise ... along with others. I thought their process of engagement with their premium customers was excellent. Its a shame you didn’t have the chance to be involved, it seems like you would have appreciated the opportunity.
    No member give thanks

  • Flying High

    Flying High

    12 Apr, 2019 08:14 am

    "we’re looking at redefining business class, first class, premium economy and economy."

    LOL - I can't imagine anyone is naive enough to believe this after the over-promise of the seats on the Dreamliner...
    Member who gave thanks

    Caversham04

  • Smith

    RMITLad

    12 Apr, 2019 08:35 am

    I’ve heard repeatedly Qantas wanted doors on their new First cabin refit on the 380 and move it- but CASA won’t certify it. Australian abaiation authorites are known to be conservative and were the last (if they have yet) to approve global standards. I’d say if true makes sense why the 789 doesn’t have doors either.

    David - perhaps CASA could comment on this?
    No member give thanks

  • QFcrew

    QFcrew

    12 Apr, 2019 11:29 am

    They won’t even certify the current 787 seat to be in the semi reclined mode despite the same functionality on the 330.
    No member give thanks

  • Adam T

    AT

    14 Apr, 2019 03:51 pm

    Out of interest how does CASA so no doors to Qantas, but other carriers can fly into Australia with doors a plenty without a problem. Surely doors are either a problem or they’re not, but not both?
    No member give thanks

  • MYT095

    MYT095

    15 Apr, 2019 01:48 am

    The aircraft are not registered in Australia and thus CASA has no jurisdiction.
    No member give thanks

  • Aidan

    Aidan

    12 Apr, 2019 09:12 am

    Doors are great if they are designed not to take up extra space.
    My priority list for these flights would be in the following order.
    - More seat width
    - More foot hole space when sleeping
    - Privacy door

    Also some form economy+ should be the minimum seat type with better seat pitch, width and upgraded food.
    This has to be more than just a flight, it has to be an great experience for all.
    Leisure passengers would just go on a longer route if it was just about cost.

    Easy for me to say though, as arm chair CEO.
    No member give thanks

  • reeves35

    reeves35

    12 Apr, 2019 09:17 am

    Seat width is an issue. I find it very hard to comfortably sleep on the existing J class seat without lowering the armrest. If a door arrangement means this is no longer possible then I'd probably vote no though the extra fuselage width of the 777 or A350 should mean the actual seat base can be wider than the existing 787/A330 seats.
    No member give thanks

  • Lps988

    Lps988

    12 Apr, 2019 09:40 am

    I think the key for Qantas is not just to catch up to those already providing the option of a door, but to leap frog them and really raise the bar for others to play catch up in the years to come.
    No member give thanks

  • Steve987

    Steve987

    12 Apr, 2019 08:12 pm

    Which looks like?
    No member give thanks

  • Lps988

    Lps988

    13 Apr, 2019 08:24 am

    That's up to the people who have much more creativity and engineering skills than I'll ever have.

    A good start is listening to your customer, especially those who use the product frequently.
    No member give thanks

  • Steve987

    Steve987

    14 Apr, 2019 08:18 pm

    Don’t disagree, but saying “do better” without any ideas for what better could look like isn’t really all that useful for the listener.
    No member give thanks

  • PCHammond

    PCHammond

    12 Apr, 2019 09:53 am

    Given the huge amount of positive feedback and praise for any business class with doors, "Should Qantas' Project Sunrise business class seats have doors?" seems like a rhetorical question. I can only recall a handful of people who have said that they don't like the door closed.

    Like most business travellers, I travel alone most of the time. And when I'm not travelling alone, I don't really want to talk to my travel companions much...I'm trying to get some rest to prevent jetlag. Give me doors any day
    No member give thanks

  • johnaboxall

    johnaboxall

    12 Apr, 2019 09:56 am

    No door, make the seat wider. I miss the 30" SQ J seats.
    No member give thanks

  • flyboy255

    flyboy255

    12 Apr, 2019 10:30 am

    Absolutely! one of the only complaints I have with VA's "The Business" offering...needs a privacy door.
    No member give thanks

  • Marcia Victoria Cavanagh

    Toria

    12 Apr, 2019 10:32 am

    I would prefer extra attention to insulation from passengers in surrounding suites, who turn on overhead or reading lamps right in the middle of sleeping time.
    No member give thanks

  • Fonga

    Fonga

    12 Apr, 2019 11:44 am

    No from me. Part of the appeal of choosing Qantas is to have that engagement with an FA from home.
    Is there not a safety aspect to this as well? In an emergency evac would these boxed suites become a hindrance to a quicker and safer exit?
    No member give thanks

  • Dave

    Grannular

    12 Apr, 2019 02:31 pm

    You don't Have to close the door though. You are welcome to keep it open and interact with the FA's
    No member give thanks

  • Pcoder

    Pcoder

    12 Apr, 2019 12:06 pm

    I'd also like satellite television (cnn, bbc world, cnbc, sport 24, and possibly Abc Australia ) on board all the sunrise aircraft as I like to keep abreast of things that are happening on the ground. I recently travelled on the cx a35k and this was a nice feature.
    No member give thanks

  • L Mck

    Lmc

    12 Apr, 2019 12:39 pm

    And how long will it be until we want a flat bed in premium economy.
    Business class today is what first class was 10 + years ago. Nothing wrong with that, just makes first class obsolete.
    No member give thanks

  • mviy

    mviy

    12 Apr, 2019 01:51 pm

    They should add a shower for first class like Emirates does on the A380. They need to do something to make First Class stand out more.
    No member give thanks

  • Jedinak K

    Jedinak K

    12 Apr, 2019 02:51 pm

    Showers = extra water = extra weight. Not something they would be keen on when trying to make these non-stop flights.
    No member give thanks

  • RTWFF

    RTWFF

    13 Apr, 2019 08:40 am

    How much extra weight will doors add?
    No member give thanks

  • A Lian

    anurax

    14 Apr, 2019 01:21 am

    Based on your theory then it’s just a name change without any much meaning if you take away F and make J the new F and PE the new J. Seems like the industry is gone silly. Keep things in perspective and for what they are and stop moving goal post and then move the field along with it in the end
    No member give thanks

  • Jason Hamilton

    JKH

    12 Apr, 2019 12:40 pm

    It’s hoses for courses and corrals for cattle.
    No member give thanks

  • Places_to_go

    Places_to_go

    12 Apr, 2019 01:03 pm

    Yes please. I don’t socialise on flights, and do 95% of my travelling alone.
    No member give thanks

  • RTWFF

    RTWFF

    13 Apr, 2019 08:41 am

    All you need do is say very firmly “I’m frightfully sorry but I don’t speak English”
    No member give thanks

  • John Phelan

    John Phelan

    12 Apr, 2019 01:18 pm

    I have travelled on airlines with doors on suites and have never used them. I just don't understand why they are necessary.

     
    Unless they - and the suite walls - extend all the way to the ceiling, then anyone walking past can see you over the top of the walls anyway. So it really makes no difference to "privacy".
     
    I much prefer spacious open-plan cabins. I don't want to be stuck in a cubicle. It's also not great from either a service or safety perspective.
    No member give thanks

  • Steve987

    Steve987

    12 Apr, 2019 08:14 pm

    This is the key. I think I read that the BA door is 130cm-ish high? My pre-teen is taller than that!
    No member give thanks

  • oldfolky

    oldfolky

    12 Apr, 2019 02:29 pm

    Doors just seem like wasted weight to me. I’m not sure why they are necessary or why the illusion of privacy is so necessary. Illusion in that the doors barely come up to waist height and can be easily looked over.

    If doors actually closed of a section of cabin it might be a different matter. It would be great to be able to open the window blind without disturbing one’s neighbours. On something like the project sunrise trip it would be good to regulate the circadian rhythms with natural light.
    No member give thanks

  • StudiodeKadent

    StudiodeKadent

    12 Apr, 2019 02:54 pm

    Some business travellers need the doors if they're working on something that requires confidentiality. So as such, the door is useful for them.

    But honestly I don't see the door as vital for privacy. Generous privacy shields work well enough to provide a highly private experience. Doors are only really necessary if the seats themselves face into the aisle. Reverse herringbone without a door is private enough.

    Also, QF have weight requirements for Project Sunrise. Doors add weight.
    No member give thanks

  • Joe

    Joe

    12 Apr, 2019 03:59 pm

    They could always take a loo or two out for weight saving? Don't laugh....I bet my bottom dollar that was a valid considered option at the weight saving strategy meeting at QCC!!
    Member who gave thanks

    ozzieflyer

  • James O'Mahony

    Ourmanin

    12 Apr, 2019 06:01 pm

    I’ve got to say some of these replies made me laugh (in a good way) the Rod Liddle phrase is great :) Personally (and ultimately it is a personal decision) I’ve found myself looking the idea of doors more than the reality. I love Q suites. But I rarely, if ever, close the doors. I just don’t feel the need. Others clearly love being able to. For Qantas then, in joining all the other armchair CEO’s, I imagine these are routes that will face very little if any competition on a direct flight basis. My only concern of fitting doors (which can of course be left open) is if they impede on the space available, especially in terms of seat width. As on such long flight comfort is going to be the most important feature.
    No member give thanks

  • Balta  Caceres

    Aircraft Lover

    12 Apr, 2019 07:40 pm

    Most of the modern Business Class seat shells are made of ultra-light composite materials

    The seat-suite door is usually very light
    No member give thanks

  • Say Mee

    mspcooper

    13 Apr, 2019 07:14 am

    They could have one of those electronically manageable windows made as “doors” that cover the ceiling and sides (and one that can be moved) for privacy. To be honest, the straight seats on the new business suite on QF aircrafts are miles better than SQ and VA (angled seats). More leg/knee room when lying around is a lot more important than a privacy door IMHO.
    I wonder why they could not do stepped seats/beds, so the “lower level” and “upper level” pax can get good leg and shoulder room.
    No member give thanks

  • Clancy

    Clancy

    13 Apr, 2019 08:00 am

    But what would the voyeurs do for 18-19hrs?

    Seriously, I'm not that important and nor is the work that I do, so doors are not a things for me.

    No member give thanks

  • M Will

    Plat 1

    13 Apr, 2019 05:18 pm

    Would need more information to make a sensible contribution to the door debate. If Qantas is reading...Qantas never ask their best customers, why? Current Qantas business class beds are just terrible. Did anyone test the beds? Seats are uncomfortable, no foot room, no variation to allow interaction when travelling together. To answer the door question would need to be a broader discussion
    No member give thanks

  • Ross

    Ross

    14 Apr, 2019 04:11 pm

    I really like the concept of curtains that AF uses in F, I'm not a big fan of the doors.
    No member give thanks

  • Trogdor

    Trogdor

    15 Apr, 2019 09:14 am

    Staggering the seats so you don't see directly across to your neighbor across the aisle would probably fulfill my need for privacy, given people walking past my seat can see over a door anyway.

    Some way to further deaden noise and carefully positioned lighting that doesn't shine around the cabin would help me relax more versus a door.
    No member give thanks

  • jtung

    jtung

    15 Apr, 2019 12:37 pm

    Qantas is a prestigious airline, however they should also consider lifting their game for their current hard products as well as soft products, such as service.Qantas should from first to economy(seats,comfort,food etc.) revolutionalise the way of air travel in the 2020s and beyond. Also, David would you be able to provide an update on Cathay Pacific's new seats as well for the 777x as well as the routes they plan to implement
    No member give thanks

  • Balta  Caceres

    Aircraft Lover

    15 Apr, 2019 05:35 pm


    Some airlines are developing acoustic insulation inside the Business Class seat shell, that works much better with a suite door installed
    No member give thanks

Guest

22 May, 2019 01:06 am

×
×

Forgot Password

If you’ve forgotten your password, simply enter your email address below, then click 'Submit'. We’ll send you an email to re-activate your account and enter a new password.

×

Resend activation email

If you have not received the activation email, simply enter your email address below, then click 'Submit'. We’ll send you an email containing the activation link.

×